DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.
DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.DowngradedOur downstream service providers are currently experiencing outages, and our engineering team is actively working on a resolution. Some services—including the Solver, Partner, and Tools—are temporarily degraded with higher latency and lower bandwidth. Rest assured, Intervipedia, Solutions, and the Question Bank features are not impacted and remain fully operational.
The Question
SQL

Top-Selling Products by Category

Given a table product_spend representing Amazon transactions, write a query to identify the top 2 products in terms of total revenue for each category during the year 2022. Your output should display the category name, the product name, and the total spend associated with that product. In cases of identical spend within a category, ensure the ranking logic is consistent with standard business reporting (e.g., handling ties).
Clickhouse
Window Function
CTE
RANK
Aggregation
Questions & Insights

Clarifying Questions

Clarifying Questions

How should ties be handled? If two products in the same category have the exact same total spend, should both be included (possibly returning more than 2 rows) or should we pick one based on another attribute? Assumption: We will use `RANK()` to include ties, but typically in these puzzles, `ROW_NUMBER()` is used to strictly limit to two records. I will provide a solution using `RANK()` for business accuracy.
What is the data type of `transaction_date`? Is it a Date or DateTime? Assumption: It is a `DateTime` or `Date` object, and we will use ClickHouse's `toYear()` function for extraction.
Are there multiple categories per product?Assumption: A product belongs to a single category for the purpose of this calculation as per the schema provided.
Is the `spend` column guaranteed to be positive?Assumption: Yes, though the logic holds for negative values (returns) as well.

Data Model Assumptions

Table Type:product_spend is an Event Fact table (likely stored using the MergeTree engine).
Primary Key / Sorting Key: In a production ClickHouse environment, this table is likely sorted by (category, transaction_date, product) to optimize for this specific query pattern.
Schema:
category: String (Dimension)
product: String (Dimension)
user_id: UInt32/UInt64 (Foreign Key to Users)
spend: Decimal64(2) or Float64 (Metric)
transaction_date: DateTime (Event Timestamp)
---

Thinking Process

Filter First: To optimize performance in ClickHouse, we must filter the transaction_date for the year 2022 immediately. Using toYear(transaction_date) = 2022 is standard, though range filters (e.g., transaction_date >= '2022-01-01') are often faster if an index exists.
Aggregate: Group by category and product to calculate the total spend. This reduces the dataset size significantly before applying window functions.
Rank: Apply a window function RANK() (or ROW_NUMBER()) partitioned by the category and ordered by the total_spend in descending order.
Final Filter: Wrap the ranked data in a CTE or subquery and filter for ranks 1 and 2.
ClickHouse Specifics: ClickHouse supports standard SQL window functions since version 21.x. For earlier versions, one would use groupArray and arraySlice, but modern ClickHouse syntax prefers the standard RANK() OVER (...).
---
Implementation Breakdown

Problem Set

Goal: Identify the top 2 products by total spend per category in 2022.
Output:category, product, total_spend.
Constraints: Must handle the year 2022 specifically.
Edge Cases: Categories with only one product; products with identical spend (ties).
---

Approach

CTEs: Used for readability and to separate the aggregation layer from the ranking layer.
Window Functions:RANK() used to handle ties (or ROW_NUMBER() for a strict 2-row limit).
Date Functions:toYear() for high-performance date part extraction.
Computational Cost:O(N \log N) due to sorting for the window function, where N is the number of unique product-category pairs in 2022.
---

Implementation

---
Wrap Up

Advanced Topics

Indexing & Projections: For massive datasets, creating a Projection that pre-aggregates spend by category, product, and year would make this query return in milliseconds.
Engine Selection: If this query is run frequently, using a SummingMergeTree engine for a materialized view would allow ClickHouse to pre-calculate the sums in the background.
Memory Management: If the number of unique products is extremely high, we might need to adjust max_bytes_before_external_group_by to prevent OOM (Out of Memory) errors during the GROUP BY phase.
Alternative for Old Versions: In very old ClickHouse versions without window functions, one would use:
    SELECT 
        category,
        groupArray(2)(tuple(total_spend, product)) as top_products
    FROM (...) 
    GROUP BY category
This uses ClickHouse's powerful array functions to keep only the top 2 elements per group.